How to choose an accountant and not overpay
Want to get a tax refund after the season, deal with a letter, or file a return? First define the task. Paid help is not needed in every case.
Your password and login code for the tax account stay with you. For an accountant to work, there is a separate HMRC permission — the UK tax authority.
Where do you want to start?
I am a seasonal worker. Do I need an accountant?
Define the task → check the free path → decide
Look at your payslip and the letter
PAYE is the withholding of tax by the employer from wages. Seasonal work by itself does not oblige you to buy an accountant's services or file a Self Assessment.
For a refund, start with the instructions
There are free ways to contact HMRC about overpaid tax on wages. The refund depends on your tax and income, not on an intermediary's promise.
If it is difficult — ask for help
You can contact HMRC or check TaxAid's conditions. With complex income or a dispute, choose a specialist with experience in your exact situation.
I want to check a specialist
Name and firm → confirmation of status → experience
Find out who you are entrusting the work to
Ask for the full name, firm name, contacts and terms. A friend's recommendation is useful, but it does not replace a check.
Check the stated details
If the specialist names a professional organisation, find them or the firm in its official register. Compare the name and get in touch using an independent contact.
Ask about similar cases
Working with a seasonal worker's wages, leaving the UK and foreign income requires different experience. Clarify who will personally check the result and answer questions.
What to check before paying?
Full price → written terms → secure permission
Ask for the final price
What is included, is VAT included, is there a minimum fee and extra charges? If they take a percentage of the refund, ask for a calculation of how much you will get.
Agree on the result and the deadline
State in writing the tax year, the specific service, the deadline, the documents and the complaint procedure. Do not sign a blank return or unclear terms.
Keep control of the account
Use the appropriate way to authorise an agent through HMRC. Do not give away your password or one-time login code.
I paid, but there is a problem
Keep the evidence → protect access → demand an answer
Collect the documents
Keep the contract, the payment, the correspondence, the submitted forms and the promised deadline. Ask for a copy of the completed work and confirmation of submission.
If someone else has access, act immediately
If there are unknown changes in your account, report it to HMRC. If you can log in, change your password. Separately check and, if needed, revoke the agent's authority.
Write a specific request
Describe what was not done and what outcome you expect. Use the firm's complaints procedure; for a regulated professional, check their organisation's procedure.
All guide topics
Checks, documents and details
When you need help and when you can start on your own
First, define one task: check the tax in your pay, get a refund after leaving, reply to a letter, or prepare a return. These are different services. Do not buy an "all taxes" package until it is clear what you specifically need.
If you only have pay through PAYE, start with your personal tax account and HMRC guidance. Having other income or a requirement to file a return changes the situation. Do not register as self-employed just to get a tax refund.
Paid help can be useful if it is hard to gather documents, understand the calculation, or deal with a dispute. It does not remove your responsibility for the information sent to HMRC.
Where to start for free
GOV.UK has guidance and HMRC contacts. If it is hard to use the online service, check the available ways to get extra support. Do not move to paying just because the first letter is unclear.
TaxAid helps people who need tax help and cannot afford a specialist. The organisation has criteria and limits: check them on the website first. Help is not guaranteed to every applicant.
Four registers you can start with
ICAEW and ACCA let you search for specialists or firms linked to these organisations. In ACCA, select the country you need. AAT publishes a directory of licensed accountants and accounting specialists. CIOT lets you check a tax specialist's membership.
Search by full name or firm name, and check the status and contacts. If the result is unclear, confirm with the organisation itself. A screenshot of a certificate in a messaging app is easier to fake than an entry on an official website.
These are examples, not a complete list of acceptable specialists. Not being in one of these registers does not by itself prove fraud. Being listed in a directory does not guarantee a result in your case.
What to ask about qualifications
"Accountant" and a verified professional title are not the same thing. Ask for the name of the qualification, the organisation, and the number to check it. If a practising licence is claimed, ask about its current status and the services it allows.
Ask: "Have you worked with seasonal workers who have left the UK? Who will prepare and check my documents? In what language will you explain the calculation?" Also ask about professional indemnity insurance and the complaints procedure.
AML and HMRC registration are different checks
AML is supervision of compliance with anti-money-laundering rules. For accounting services, supervision may be carried out by HMRC or a professional organisation; there are exceptions. Ask who supervises this firm and how to check it.
A firm not being in the HMRC AML register does not necessarily mean there is no supervision: it may belong to another organisation. Being in the register is not itself a recommendation from HMRC or a guarantee of quality.
From May 2026, phased mandatory registration of paid tax representatives with HMRC is being introduced. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the situation. Check the applicable requirements; do not confuse this registration with a qualification, AML, or your personal authorisation for an agent.
How to compare price without a surprise fee
Ask for two or three quotes for the same work and one tax year. Clarify: is it a fixed amount, an hourly rate, or a percentage? What happens if there is no refund? Is there a minimum, an upfront payment, or an extra charge for corrections and replies to HMRC?
Compare the full amount with VAT, if it is charged. Example calculation: £200 plus 20% VAT = £240. This is a calculation example, not a market price for a service. If a price is given as "from", ask for the conditions under which it increases.
With a commission from a refund, clarify the base for the percentage, VAT, additional fees, and the amount that will remain for you. A fixed price by itself does not guarantee honesty; a percentage by itself does not prove fraud. Clear terms and completed work are what matter.
What to agree in writing
In the contract or letter of engagement, the provider, your tasks, tax years, deadlines, price, and the parties' responsibilities must be clear. Clarify whether the price includes checking documents, filing, correcting errors, and answering follow-up questions from HMRC.
Separately ask about cancelling the service, refunds, complaints, and possible work in the following years. Record where the tax refund will arrive and who withholds the commission. Do not assume a one-off application is automatically a one-off contract.
Keep the terms before payment together with the invoice and proof of payment. If you are asked to pay a different recipient, first get a clear explanation of the connection to the provider.
What documents to prepare
For a conversation about pay, payslips, P45 or P60, HMRC letters and employment dates are usually useful. If you are discussing leaving, prepare your arrival and departure dates. For a tax return, you may need details of other income and expenses.
Ask for a list that is specific to your task and a safe way to send it. Identity checks can be a legitimate part of AML procedures. But that is not a reason to hand over your account password or login code. Do not post your passport, National Insurance number or UTR in a group chat.
How to give authority and keep your own access
Your phone, email and login details should stay under your control. An agent acts through an allowed HMRC method for the relevant tax: this may be an online process or form 64-8. One method does not work for all services.
Do not confuse a one-time login code with a separate agent authorisation code from an HMRC letter. In some processes the latter needs to be passed to the agent you have chosen. Read the purpose of the code and the instructions on GOV.UK; if it is unclear, check with HMRC first.
Before confirming, check which agent and which permissions are shown. Keep a copy of the authorisation. A representative may get access to tax information and actions on it: this is not just "looking at the balance".
When it is better to stop and check
Do not agree to invented expenses, empty forms or a guaranteed refund before the documents have been checked. A demand to hand over your password, hide part of your income or pay urgently without conditions is a reason to stop sharing data and check the offer.
A messenger app, remote work or the absence of an expensive office do not by themselves prove fraud. Judge by verifiable information, written terms and specific actions. If the answers are evasive, you can choose another provider.
Checks before the first payment
Go through a short list: who the provider is; what confirms the status they claim; whether they have experience with your task; what the full price is; what result and deadline are promised; what permissions are needed; how to make a complaint.
Keep the answers in one place. If you are unsure, do not send new documents or money until things are clear.
Before filing and after it
Ask for the finished tax return or application before it is sent. Check the name, tax year, income, expenses, bank details and amount. Ask them to explain lines you do not understand; do not confirm something you cannot check.
After filing, get a copy and confirmation of submission. Separately check the bill, payment deadlines and refund status in HMRC. Paying your accountant does not mean your tax has been paid.
If you want to stop working with an agent
Check the terms for ending the contract and tell the provider your decision in writing. Separately cancel any authorisations you no longer need in HMRC: ending the contract and removing access are different actions.
The way to cancel depends on the tax and on how the agent was authorised. If there is Self Assessment and Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, separate actions may be needed for both. Use the current HMRC instructions and keep the confirmations.
If the work was not done or there is a mistake
Write to the firm: which service you paid for, what was promised, what happened, what you are asking for and which documents are attached. Ask for a reply under its complaints procedure. Even during a dispute, keep an eye on HMRC deadlines and the correction of incorrect information.
If the professional belongs to a professional body, check its complaints rules. For example, ICAEW deals with certain breaches by its members and firms, but does not resolve ordinary disputes about fees or a contract. A complaint does not guarantee compensation.
If there is unknown activity in your account, tell HMRC straight away. If you suspect an unauthorised payment, also contact your bank or payment service and check the available process for disputing it.
If there is CIS, rental income, a company or overseas income
For income from construction work through CIS you need experience with the relevant deductions and tax return. For rental income, a Ltd company, foreign income, residence or an HMRC check, check for experience specifically in that area.
Do not choose a service just because of a general "tax refund" label. Describe all sources of income and circumstances in advance. The type of visa does not by itself determine tax residence, and the cheapest quote may not include the work you need.
If you only need an overpayment after the season
Start with the free HMRC route. The way to claim depends on whether you are still working, whether you are leaving the UK and whether you file a Self Assessment return. Do not create a second claim until you have found out the status of the first.
If you ask an agent to handle the refund, find out in advance who receives the money, the full fee and how the contract works for the following years. An accountant or intermediary cannot guarantee an HMRC decision, an exact amount or a payment date.
Frequent questions
Does a seasonal worker have to pay an accountant?
No. For pay through PAYE and claiming an overpayment there are free HMRC routes. Help is chosen based on the specific task and how complex the situation is.
If someone is not in ACCA, are they a fraudster?
No. There are other organisations and ways of working. Check the specific information and status they claim, as well as their experience and terms.
Is a fixed price safer than a percentage?
No scheme by itself guarantees honesty. Compare the total cost, extra charges, the result and the contract terms.
What is a normal price for a tax return?
There is no universal price: it depends on the work and the complexity. Request several comparable quotes with VAT, if it is charged, and all additional charges.
Do I need to give my Government Gateway password?
No. A separate HMRC procedure is used for an agent. The password and the one-time login code stay with you.
Can I pass on the authorisation code from the HMRC letter?
If it is a special code for authorising a chosen agent, the relevant procedure may require it. It is not the login code for the account. Check its purpose in the official instructions.
Is a request to show a passport always suspicious?
No. The provider may need to verify identity. Clarify the reason and a safe channel for sending it; the password and login code are not needed for this.
Does registration in the AML register guarantee quality?
No. It is a separate type of supervision, not approval of the service or a guarantee of a refund. Supervision may also be carried out by a professional body.
Are all tax agents already required to go through the new HMRC registration?
The requirements are being introduced in stages from May 2026, with different deadlines and exceptions. Check the current rules for the specific provider.
The accountant filed the return. Do I have nothing left to do?
Check the copy, the confirmation of submission, the calculation and the payment deadlines. You remain responsible for your tax information.
Does removing an agent in HMRC mean terminating the contract?
These are different actions. Separately check the terms for ending the service and cancel the authorisation for the relevant taxes.
I paid, but there is no response. What should I keep?
The contract, the invoice, the proof of payment, the correspondence and the promised deadlines. Demand the result or an explanation in writing; if someone else has access to the account, tell HMRC immediately.
Official instructions and registers
- HMRC: free help with a return
- TaxAid: check the conditions for free help
- HMRC: how to choose a tax agent
- HMRC: authorise an agent to act on your behalf
- HMRC: report someone else's access to your account
- HMRC: change or cancel an agent's authority
- HMRC: check this year's tax
- ICAEW: find a specialist or firm
- ACCA: find a firm
- AAT: find an accountant
- CIOT: check membership
- AAT: licensing and types of services
- HMRC: who is subject to AML supervision
- HMRC: check AML registration
- HMRC: who needs tax representative registration and when
- GOV.UK: VAT rates
- HMRC: appoint a tax agent
- HMRC: authorise an agent to act on your behalf
- ICAEW: make a complaint and check what it covers
- HMRC: choose a refund method